baseMinSD 1.5 line, so this is a COIL
(balance at equilibrium), not a BASE (digestion at an extreme).5-DMA note: VZ closed one session a hair under the daily 5-DMA (8/12: 46.98 vs 47.07) and reclaimed it 8/13. One day below is a flicker, not a pullback — which is exactly why a reclaim engine with a 2-day persistence gate ignores it (next slide).
The plan was written the night before — overnight scan: leg-up + consolidation, if it takes the prior-day high, buy it; stop under the box at 46.81 (the VRVP shelf).
One chart, one set of 30-minute candles. The lens changes only the overlays, the markers and the explanation — the trade underneath never changes. Signals are the computed engine events; BUY/SELL arrows are the actual reconciled fills.
The canonical MTF Strategy Lens mounted in this page (house chart theme: white, hollow black candles; σ + AM ATR renderers; chart TF 1m → Daily; reconciled executions; Candle / Event Inspector). Full page: lens.html?ticker=VZ&date=2026-08-13.
| Session | Engine event | Gate that decided it | Consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8/4 09:30 | RECLAIM ↑ VALID bowl 0.74 ATR ≥ 0.5 depth, 2+ days below, slope OK | FAILED_AT_OPEN — the confirm bar closed back through the basis (−0.10 ATR tolerance) |
No play. Break-confirm level armed at 47.81 (prior session high) |
| 8/7 09:30 | RECLAIM ↑ VALID bowl 1.30 ATR — a real dip, easily deep enough | FAILED_AT_OPEN again — soft open, close under the line |
No play. Break-confirm re-armed at 47.48 (prior session high) |
| 8/8–8/11 | Break-confirm window open (3 sessions) | Needs one confirmed 30-min close > 47.48. VZ’s grind topped at ~47.45 on 8/11 and pulled back 8/12 | Never triggered — by 0.03–0.36 on the closes |
| 8/12 09:30 | BRK_EXPIRED | brkWin = 3 sessions elapsed |
Engine goes idle. One session before the breakout. |
| 8/13 → 8/28 | Silent | Re-arming requires a fresh daily-close reclaim, which requires 2+ daily closes below the basis first. VZ never closed below the 5-DMA again during the entire run (one flicker 8/27) | Structurally invisible. The 8/13 breakout started from above the mean — a pullback-reclaim engine has no state for it |
No — but it was honest filtering. The gates that stayed shut are gates that exist for good reasons (soft opens after reclaims do fail; stale break levels do go dead). VZ is the case where those gates cost the trade: the reclaims were real, the structure was real, and requiring both engines would have filtered out a +1.14R realized / +4.53R MFE trade. One case proves cost, not policy — that is what the Type B tally is for.
AM ATR answers "has a broken name repaired itself?" — reclaim of the mean after a real bowl. Adaptive Mean + σ answers "is a working name loading up again?" — compression at the mean inside a trend. VZ was the second question. CRWD (7/31) was both at once, which is why both engines fired there. Structure/location vs momentum/execution — supported by these two cases, proven by neither.
| Entry (ET) | Qty | Entry | Exit (ET) | Exit | P&L | Leg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 08-13 09:23 | 100 | 47.11 | 08-13 09:29 | 47.01 | -10.00 | flush trim |
| 08-13 09:23 | 50 | 47.12 | 08-13 09:29 | 47.01 | -5.50 | flush trim |
| 08-13 09:23 | 50 | 47.11 | 08-13 09:29 | 47.01 | -5.00 | flush trim |
| 08-13 09:23 | 40 | 47.12 | 08-13 09:42 | 47.25 | +5.20 | intraday bank |
| 08-13 09:23 | 60 | 47.11 | 08-13 09:42 | 47.25 | +8.40 | intraday bank |
| 08-13 09:23 | 100 | 47.11 | 08-13 10:34 | 47.48 | +36.50 | intraday bank |
| 08-13 09:23 | 50 | 47.11 | 08-13 13:43 | 47.80 | +34.75 | intraday bank |
| 08-13 09:30 | 50 | 47.11 | 08-14 12:58 | 48.37 | +63.00 | swing piece |
| 08-13 09:50 | 10 | 47.25 | 08-14 12:58 | 48.37 | +11.20 | swing piece |
| 08-13 09:50 | 90 | 47.25 | 08-17 09:30 | 48.17 | +82.80 | swing piece |
All 8/13-entered VZ shares, matched-trade rows from InfoCenter (TG814859). The 09:29 trim of 200 sh at 47.01 is the opening flush; the plan stop 46.81 never traded. Gross on the swing: +$221.35 (+1.14R) against $194.90 at risk.
Both engines agree. CRWD 7/31: coil + 5-DMA reclaim + PDH break (σ) and a break-confirm long the same bar (ATR). Study: does agreement raise expectancy or just comfort?
σ engine has a valid structural signal, ATR silent. VZ 8/13 is the specimen. Trend-continuation out of a coil above the mean — the shape reclaim engines cannot see.
ATR play fires without a qualifying σ structure. No manufactured example here — find real ones in the signal log as they occur.
Neither engine. The baseline that makes the other three measurable.
| CRWD 7/31 | VZ 8/13 | |
|---|---|---|
| Adaptive Mean + σ | ✓ coil 7/27–28 → PDH break → VWAP play (E 191.21) | ✓ coil 8/10 → structure 8/11 → PDH break + expansion 8/13 (own Play-1: 47.67) |
| AM ATR v4.2x | ✓ brk-confirm LONG 7/31, T1 8/3, exit 8/17 +2.1R | — silent: BRK_EXPIRED 8/12, no reclaim path after |
| Compression | COIL near mean, 13.5–19.6%ile (TV/port), after a −20% flush | COIL near mean, 15.8%ile, inside an uptrend leg |
| 5-DMA state | Reclaimed 7/30 after 6 sessions below — flat → rounding up | Rising throughout; one 1-day flicker below (8/12), no real loss |
| Structural trigger | PDH 185.46 break → box-high 191.21 | strength-high 47.115 broke 8/11 (HL 46.80) → PDH 47.08 on trade day |
| Expansion | 1σ break 7/30–31, bands widening (RVOL 0.92 — tagged, not gated) | 1σ break 8/13 09:30, bands widening out of the coil |
| Actual entry | 191.21 · stop 187.98 (hold low) · 2R banker 197.68 | 47.135 avg · plan stop 46.81 · scaled to 48.37/48.17 |
| Best classification | TYPE A — CONFLUENCE | TYPE B — ADAPTIVE STRUCTURE |
| Key lesson | Where the engines converge, size with confidence — entry was never the problem | Location + structure can be sufficient; the missing ATR event was mechanics, not quality — and both trades left the runner |
signal_family + atr_no_signal_reason fields in
playbook_data/ exist so every future trade grows the tally.playbook_data/vz_2026-08-13.json