J3P Backtest — Edge Read VCET-conditioned

James Three Plays (Pull-In / Trend / Backside) on the SIP watchlist · 10 trading days ending 2026-06-26 · 5-min bars · generated 2026-06-27 ET
Trades157 Total P&L (per $100 risk/trade)$-2,715 Win %47.1% Avg R-0.171

Verdict — where the edge is (and isn't)

Edge gate for hotkeys (Stage 4): only positive-expectancy cells (avg_R>0, with enough n) advance. Today that's Trend / grade B–C / TREND_UP. Pull-In advances only once regime-gated. Backside does not advance.

By Playbook

playbooknwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
trend_trade4728$361.49+0.078+1.099-0.79259.6%
vwap_pull_in10645$-2,410.07-0.226+0.454-0.64642.5%
backside_scalp41$-666.59-1.669+18.746-5.50725.0%

By Playbook × Grade

playbookgradenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
trend_tradeB86$303.77+0.383+1.233-0.70275.0%
trend_tradeA21$17.10+0.084+0.324-0.48050.0%
trend_tradeC3721$40.62+0.012+1.112-0.82856.8%
vwap_pull_inA31$-3.76-0.016+0.415-0.22833.3%
vwap_pull_in-9843$-2,234.00-0.226+0.461-0.65243.9%
vwap_pull_inC21$-53.97-0.266+0.730-0.57650.0%
vwap_pull_inB30$-118.34-0.394+0.063-0.9300.0%
backside_scalpB41$-666.59-1.669+18.746-5.50725.0%

By Playbook × VCET Regime (the conditioning that matters)

playbookvcet_statenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_inFAILED_EXPANSION_CONFIRMED11$73.44+0.721+1.336-0.061100.0%
vwap_pull_inCOMPRESSION22$67.58+0.339+0.454-0.274100.0%
vwap_pull_inTREND_DOWN22$50.95+0.261+0.404-0.302100.0%
trend_tradeTREND_UP4728$361.49+0.078+1.099-0.79259.6%
vwap_pull_inTREND_UP62$-64.57-0.107+0.366-0.58233.3%
vwap_pull_inROTATION9438$-2,429.13-0.257+0.454-0.66340.4%
vwap_pull_inMEAN_REVERSION10$-108.34-1.066+0.188-1.5010.0%
backside_scalpMEAN_REVERSION10$-109.03-1.090+0.123-4.6660.0%
backside_scalpROTATION31$-557.56-1.862+24.953-5.78733.3%

By Playbook × Tier

playbooktiernwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
trend_trade1st_dev4728$361.49+0.078+1.099-0.79259.6%
vwap_pull_inband15626$-769.41-0.136+0.430-0.48646.4%
vwap_pull_inband33717$-934.64-0.251+0.545-0.82745.9%
vwap_pull_inband2132$-706.02-0.541+0.295-0.82415.4%
backside_scalpext41$-666.59-1.669+18.746-5.50725.0%

Full edge gate — Playbook × Grade × Tier × Regime

playbookgradetiervcet_statenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_in-band1FAILED_EXPANSION_CONFIRMED11$73.44+0.721+1.336-0.061100.0%
vwap_pull_in-band3TREND_UP11$51.84+0.515+1.064-0.340100.0%
vwap_pull_in-band1TREND_DOWN11$41.16+0.428+0.677-0.098100.0%
trend_tradeB1st_devTREND_UP86$303.77+0.383+1.233-0.70275.0%
vwap_pull_in-band1COMPRESSION22$67.58+0.339+0.454-0.274100.0%
vwap_pull_in-band2TREND_DOWN11$9.79+0.094+0.130-0.506100.0%
trend_tradeA1st_devTREND_UP21$17.10+0.084+0.324-0.48050.0%
vwap_pull_in-band1TREND_UP21$4.57+0.021+0.471-0.35750.0%
trend_tradeC1st_devTREND_UP3721$40.62+0.012+1.112-0.82856.8%
vwap_pull_inAband3ROTATION31$-3.76-0.016+0.415-0.22833.3%
vwap_pull_inBband2TREND_UP20$-15.11-0.076+0.094-0.6880.0%
vwap_pull_in-band1ROTATION4820$-902.19-0.186+0.391-0.51341.7%
vwap_pull_inCband1ROTATION21$-53.97-0.266+0.730-0.57650.0%
vwap_pull_in-band3ROTATION3215$-874.38-0.271+0.553-0.87846.9%
vwap_pull_in-band2ROTATION81$-491.60-0.612+0.440-0.79412.5%
vwap_pull_inBband2ROTATION10$-103.23-1.029+0.000-1.4140.0%
vwap_pull_in-band2TREND_UP10$-105.87-1.048+0.000-1.0660.0%
vwap_pull_in-band3MEAN_REVERSION10$-108.34-1.066+0.188-1.5010.0%
backside_scalpBextMEAN_REVERSION10$-109.03-1.090+0.123-4.6660.0%
backside_scalpBextROTATION31$-557.56-1.862+24.953-5.78733.3%

Method & caveats

Symbols: CALY, SOXL, LLY, CASY, VMI, BH, AYI, BE, PRAX, FTAI, SQQQ. Bars: real 1-min from karb/kti, aggregated to 5-min. Regime tag: VCET v1.1 engine (vcet_state) per session. Plays mirror J3P_v2.2_SIP_Webhook.pine: Pull-In = VWAP recapture after a shakeout (LB3 stop, +2σ/+4σ ladder, 80/20); Trend = Dale 1st-deviation pullback in an uptrend (stop = reaction point); Backside = ≥2·ATR extension above VWAP + rejection (stop above failed high, cover into VWAP). Entries fill next-bar open with conservative slippage (≥1¢ or 0.10×bar range); stops add adverse slip; 0.5¢/sh commission both sides. Constant $100 risk/trade sizing so an $18 name and a $248 leveraged ETF are comparable — total P&L therefore reads as "if you'd risked $100 per trade." R = net P&L ÷ initial risk. Entries gated to RTH 09:30–15:55 ET; force-flat 15:45 ET; one long + one backside slot per name (no pyramiding). Sample is 10 days — treat single-digit-n cells as directional, not conclusive; the meaningful signals here are Trend (n=47) and the ROTATION pull-in bleed (n=94). Bands use the engine's session VWAP+σ (premarket-inclusive, same yardstick as the regime tag). Roadmap: SIP→Indicators→g8trade plan.