J3P Exit Ladder — Out-of-Sample Verdict (James's 60/20/20 Shannon/Dale ladder, graded honestly)

Broad sample: 28 names × 8 sessions (locked SIP allowlist + 7/1 in-play). Exit = your ladder: 60% at +2σ (T1), 20% at +4σ (T2), 20% trailed on the higher-TF higher-low. Swept trail×T1×T2, optimized on the first 5 sessions, reported on the held-out last 3. ← J3P hub · replays →
🧪 LAB — this is a disciplined out-of-sample grade of your strategy. It is honest, not flattering.
🕹️ COCKPIT — the Pine. Nothing here is promoted — nothing held out-of-sample.
⛔ Verdict: no edge survives the honest test. The thin 3-name sample (that showed +0.25R) was over-fit. On 28 names: the pull-in has no positive config even in-sample (best −0.129R); the backside-roll's in-sample sweet-spot (+0.157R) flips to −0.121R out-of-sample (textbook overfit). And with 76 parameter combos over ~150–220 in-sample trades, you have only ~2–3 trades per parameter — far too thin to optimize. This is a data/sample-size problem, not an exit-tuning problem. The fix is the deep-data adapter, not more knobs.

Broad-sample coverage (N per play)

PlayN (broad)N (old thin)
vwap_pull_in33842
backside_roll37641
backside492
open_drive111
band_break ⭐ (new, trend-day)380—
v_bottom ⭐ (new, reversal)236—
trend_ride ⭐ (new, continuation)358—

Out-of-sample grade (in-sample-best config → held-out result)

PlayNIS-best (trail·T1/T2/run)IN-SAMPLE ROUT-OF-SAMPLE RIS trades/paramRead
VWAP Pull-In (long)338 drop · 40/30/30 -0.129 +0.079 2.91no positive config even IN-SAMPLE — no edge
Backside Rollover (short)376 swing · 40/0/60 +0.157 -0.121 1.89IS sweet-spot does NOT hold out-of-sample (overfit)
Band-Break Breakout (long, trend) ⭐380 bar5 · 80/0/20 -0.096 -0.063 2.11no positive config even IN-SAMPLE — no edge
V-Bottom Reclaim (long, reversal) ⭐236 bar5 · 40/30/30 -0.078 +0.293 2.16no positive config even IN-SAMPLE — no edge
Trend-Ride Continuation (long) ⭐358 bar5 · 40/30/30 -0.102 -0.129 1.68no positive config even IN-SAMPLE — no edge
band_break (your AMZN 7/1 trend-day play) catches trend breakouts (AMZN 7/1 10:28 = +0.79R) but on the broad sample most breakouts fail in chop → net negative, ~36% win. Same story: catches the good days, no confirmed edge on ~2 weeks.
Green cell background = OOS-positive; the point is that the IS-optimal cell does not stay green out-of-sample.

OOS avg-R surface — Backside Rollover

trail↓ / T1/T2→40/040/1040/2040/3050/050/1050/2050/3060/060/1060/2060/3070/070/1070/2070/3080/080/1080/20
bar5-0.03-0.03-0.03-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.05-0.06-0.06-0.06-0.06
bar10-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.05-0.04-0.04-0.05-0.05-0.04-0.05-0.05
swing-0.12-0.12-0.12-0.13-0.12-0.12-0.13-0.13-0.12-0.13-0.13-0.13-0.13-0.13-0.13-0.13-0.13-0.13-0.13
drop-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.04-0.05-0.04-0.04-0.05-0.05-0.04-0.05-0.05
Rows = trail method · cols = T1%/T2% split. Cell = out-of-sample avg R. Note there's no robust green plateau — the surface is noise around zero.

OOS avg-R surface — VWAP Pull-In

trail↓ / T1/T2→40/040/1040/2040/3050/050/1050/2050/3060/060/1060/2060/3070/070/1070/2070/3080/080/1080/20
bar5+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.05+0.04+0.04+0.04+0.04+0.04+0.04+0.04+0.04+0.04
bar10+0.11+0.10+0.10+0.10+0.10+0.10+0.10+0.09+0.10+0.10+0.09+0.09+0.10+0.09+0.09+0.08+0.09+0.09+0.08
swing+0.09+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.07+0.07+0.07+0.07+0.07+0.07+0.07+0.06+0.06+0.06+0.06+0.06+0.06
drop+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08+0.08

Regime filter (Shannon "trade with the daily trend")

Daily 5/10, 5/20, 10/20 MA-alignment gate (trade only when the daily trend agrees with the play), same OOS discipline:
PlayGatebaseline RIN-SAMPLE ROUT-OF-SAMPLE RRead
vwap_pull_in10/20 aligned−0.061+0.124−0.280IS lift flips hard negative OOS (overfit)
backside_roll5/20 aligned+0.022+0.184+0.018IS +0.18 decays to ~breakeven OOS (noise)
No regime gate creates a robust out-of-sample edge — the in-sample lifts don't survive. Adding a regime dimension on this sample only worsens the ~2-trades-per-parameter problem.

What this means