The post-entry fade-exit and the gap-RED / avoid-bad-type rules keep their sign out of sample. But "megacap-tech = profitable" and the entry-gate-alone FLIP to mildly negative in the test half — they're relative (least-bad) filters, not absolute edges. The test window was a much worse regime (baseline +$91 → −$389), cells are tiny (full-clean test n=7), and one IBIT trade (−$216) is >half the test loss. Verdict: durable core confirmed; promote nothing yet — run a live forward-test.
(1) Regime shift: plain Pull-In went from +$91.08 / 41.6% (train) to −$389.21 / 27.3% (test). The later weeks were simply a bad stretch for this setup; no static gate fixes that. (2) One outlier: the IBIT 6/3 trade (−$216.15, in the test half) is >55% of the entire test-half loss — ex-outlier the test baseline is −$173.06. So judge rules by whether their sign/separation persists, not by absolute P&L.
| Rule | Train avg (n) | Test avg (n) | Holds OOS? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cut the post-entry fade (fade @5min) | −$2.33 (28) | −$19.54 (23) | holds — strongest fade loses both halves; 8.7% win in test |
| Keep not-fades | +$3.19 (49) | +$0.38 (31) | holds positive/flat both |
Pass \|gap\|>1.5% (RED) | −$7.80 (31) | −$4.35 (23) | holds by win rate 25.8%→21.7%; PnL outlier-contaminated* |
| Avoid non-megacap types | −$2.56 (47) | −$9.70 (34) | holds negative both |
| "Megacap-tech = profitable" | +$7.05 (30) | −$2.83 (21) | FLIPPED relative-best only, not absolute |
Entry gate alone (megacap & \|gap\|≤1.5) | +$12.23 (21) | −$2.95 (16) | FLIPPED degrades in bad regime |
| Full stack (gate & cut fade) | +$13.57 (15) | +$6.15 (7) | holds test n=7 fade-exit rescues the gate |
| Early expansion @5min | +$10.99 (5) | +$0.81 (5) | holds tiny n |
*In the test half, the low-gap bucket (−$9.03 avg) looks worse than gap>1.5 (−$4.35) only because the IBIT −$216 outlier sits in the low-gap bucket. By win rate, gap>1.5 is still clearly worse (21.7% vs 31.2%).
The entry gate alone (megacap + controlled gap) flipped negative in test (−$2.95). Adding the post-entry rule "cut the fade" turned that same population into +$6.15 in test (full stack). In a bad regime, the entry filter isn't enough — the post-entry fade-exit is what preserves the edge. This is the most important OOS finding: the durable value is in management, not just selection. (Test n=7 — encouraging, not proven.)
Held out of sample
|gap|>1.5% (negative both by win rate)Did NOT hold out of sample
gap≤1.5 flipped negative in test (regime + outlier)HOLD promotion. The walk-forward did its job: it confirmed the durable core is the post-entry fade-exit + gap-RED + avoid-bad-type, and exposed "megacap = money" as partly favorable-regime luck. The test half is too regime- and outlier-dominated to settle promotion on history. Next step is a LIVE forward-test (the forward_test_live_log already exists) — not another historical slice. Promote nothing to production yet.
gap>1.5% RED — promoted_candidate (robust by win rate; watch outlier on PnL)